The Guardian 2 December 2024

Who is the protagonist of Robert Louis Stevenson’s adventure story? The obvious answer is Jim Hawkins, the innkeeper’s son who is drawn into a high-seas escapade complete with piracy and plundering. One minute he is helping with the customers, the next he is setting sail in search of buried treasure. But what of Long John Silver? Might not the double-crossing cook who leads a mutiny from the ship’s galley also have a claim to being the central player? After all, Stevenson’s original title was The Sea Cook: A Story for Boys.

It is a dispute that spills into Duncan McLean’s spirited adaptation of the 1883 novel, as Amy Conachan, styled as Lean Jean Silver, argues for primacy over Jade Chan as Jim. But it is Jim who wins out. He is in charge of the Admiral Benbow Home for Reformed Pirates (at least until his mum gets back) and has the final say. [READ MORE]

By Mark Fisher

MARK FISHER is a freelance theatre critic and feature writer based in Edinburgh and has written about theatre in Scotland since the late-1980s. He is a theatre critic for The Guardian, a former editor of The List magazine and a frequent contributor to the Scotsman and other publications. He is the co-editor of the play anthology Made in Scotland (1995), and the author of The Edinburgh Fringe Survival Guide (2012) and How to Write About Theatre (2015) – all Bloomsbury Methuen Drama. He is also the editor of The XTC Bumper Book of Fun for Boys and Girls and What Do You Call That Noise? An XTC Discovery Book (both Mark Fisher Ltd).